Companies who adopt a triple bottom line strategy stand to gain reduced overhead, brand advantage, employee loyalty, innovator status and contribute to a better environmental future for generations to come. The basic thrust of their case against the serious use of the tbl concept is that it is inherently misleading the term itself promises or implies something it cannot deliver. At a high level, triple bottom line sustainability is a valuesladen aspirationit is a concept that explicitly acknowledges as impor. Corporate social responsibility and the triple bottom line.
The three fundamental criticisms of the triple bottom line. The triple bottom line approach is a popular framework used for evaluating. A simple explanation of the triple bottom line university. An approach to measurement of sustainability is by using triple bottomline accounting elkington, 1997. Triple bottom line theory tbl and rateofinterest or. The triple bottom line in local government community economic development december 8, 2015 lexi herndon 0 comments a central tenet of community economic development is the belief that in fostering a healthy economy, we are working towards building healthy, vibrant communities. Sustainability, the triple bottom line, and the global.
In 1997, the phrase got currency with 1997 publication of british edition of john elkingtons cannibals with forks. Submitted in total fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of doctor of philosophy october 2015. When looking at profit from a triple bottom line standpoint, the idea is that profits will help empower and sustain the community as a whole, and not just flow to. A broader view, however, suggests that triple bottom line reporting involves assessing an entitys values, strategies and practices and how these can be utilized to achieve economic. When looking at profit from a triple bottom line standpoint, the idea is that profits will help empower and sustain the community as a whole, and not just flow to the ceo and shareholders. The tbl is an accounting framework that incorporates three dimensions of.
An approach to measurement of sustainability is by using triple bottom line accounting elkington, 1997. A stakeholder approach to triple bottom line accounting. A tbl company endeavors to benefit the natural order as much as possible or at the least do no harm and curtail environmental impact. Standardization is used as a tool for integrating social and environmental costs and benefits into the financial bottom line of an organization.
The theory behind the triple bottom line is that it is in the interests of a business to act as a steward of the environment, society and the economy. Understanding the triple bottom line, its shortcomings, and. Currently, the cost of disposing of nondegradable or toxic products is borne financially by governments and environmentally by the residents near the disposal site and elsewhere. Concept of triple bottom line reporting triple bottom line tbl reporting is a method used in business accounting to further expand stakeholders knowledge of the company. The triple bottom line exists as a kind of balanced scorecard that captures in numbers and words the degree to which any company is or is not creating value for its shareholders and society. These three bottom lines are often referred to as the three ps. While it seems straightforward enough, the triple bottom line is ripe with complexity, criticism, and alternating conceptions on what exactly it means. Another theory of corporate social responsibility is the triple bottom line. The three dimensions identify the diverse but highly interconnected components of sustainability. Triple bottom line tbl reporting is becoming more common across many sectors of society. The evolution and translation of academic theory to practice within triple bottomline management figure 3. Increased employee retention also was seen as an advantage of implementing the triple bottom line. Triple bottom line concept and its benefits for businesses. Although the triple bottom line model was introduced 30 years ago, studies show that it can still be applied in practice as well as in research ksiezak and fischbach, 2018.
It goes beyond the traditional, financial aspects and reveals the companys impact on the world around it. The triple bottom line of 21st century business elkington, 1998. Tbl reporting has been institutionalized as a way of. Triple bottom line triple bottom line tbl reporting is a method used in business accounting to further expand stakeholders. The financial bottom line is the one that all companies share, whether theyre using the triple bottom line or not. Understanding the triple bottom line, its shortcomings. This article discusses the meaning of sustainability, explores the development of the sustainability movement, and explains how businesses. Although the concept was born out of the corporate and business world to report corporate social responsibility conveniently, it has been embraced by many organisations to give social and environmental agendas more prominence in the face of corporatist. This article explores sustainability and the triple bottom line, which is a tool used to examine the effects of business activities on the economy, social equity, and environment. This casebook was created as a companion to the triple bottom line tool tbl tool in order to help illustrate what triple bottom line economic development may look like in practice and share lessons learned. When i teach the strategies in sustainability management course at harvard university in the spring, the students are required to read a journal article by wayne norman and chris macdonald, getting to the bottom of the triple bottom line. In this video i present the triple bottom line also known as 3 pillars for sustainability and suggest to use science for a new look at how the 3 pillars can be viewed. The triple bottom line or otherwise noted as tbl or 3bl is an accounting framework with three parts.
Introduction the notion of triple bottom line 3bl accounting has become increasingly. Heres how to develop strategies for csr that align with your organizations mission and deliver on the triple bottom line. Debunking the notion of a triple bottom line greenbiz. However, the lack of a common structure and language for analyzing sustainability in projects, as well as the absence of specific tools, mean the lack of a framework that can be useful and applicable to projects. Throughout the year, employees take time to reflect on their values and look for ways to give back. This study examines corporate social responsibility in sustainable development and the notion of the triple bottom line as an imperative in todays socially responsible corporation.
Material, energy, and information flows within the stages of an organizational. Csr strategies that deliver on the triple bottom line. Basically, triple bottom line tbl reporting is meant to capture, describe and measure the impact of the organisations activities on the world. A theory of social structure and action, pdf new york. Some organizations have adopted the tbl framework to evaluate their performance in a broader perspective to create greater business value. Maximizing the triple bottom line through spiritual. The triple bottom line and social responsibility framework in.
Is it possible to do so accurately and objectively. A triple bottom line to ensure corporate responsibility. According to tbl theory, companies should be working simultaneously on these three bottom lines. Corporate social responsibility, the triple bottom line. Ideas for creating an index to measure triple bottom line.
An outline of triple bottomlines contribution to profit by way of improving efficiency, compliance, and reputation of an organization figure 2. The triple bottom line in local government community economic. Many firms are realizing that having a strong sustainability or csr proleadership and the triple bottom line. A triple bottom line company does not produce harmful or destructive products such as weapons, toxic chemicals or batteries containing dangerous heavy metals for example.
This differs from traditional reporting frameworks as it includes ecological or environmental and social measures that can be difficult to assign appropriate means of measurement. The triple bottom line as the answer to the primary. What are the criteria by which we evaluate each bottom line. The triple bottom line tool tbl tool is designed to serve investors, economic development professionals, and decisionmakers in the private, public, and nonprofit sectors. The triple bottom line and social responsibility framework. In this paper, we examine critically the notion of triple bottom line accounting. Sustainability, the triple bottom line, and the global reporting initiative by paulette l. Sustainability and triple bottom line reporting what is it. It goes beyond the traditional financial aspects and reveals an organizations impact on the world around it. The triple bottom line in local government community.
We begin by asking just what it is that supporters of the triple bottom line idea advocate, and attempt to distil specific, assessable claims from the vague, diverse, and sometimes contradictory uses of the triple bottom line rhetoric. Using grounded theory as a methodological approach, the influence of triple bottom line tbl was explored as an emerging, yet substantially important phenomenon on. One way to do this is to create measurements that track more subtle examples of sustainability and the triple bottom line approach to reporting is ideal for this. Tbl reporting has been institutionalized as a way of thinking for corporate sustainability. A tbl endeavor reduces its ecological footprint by, among other things, carefully managing its consumption of energy and nonrenewable and reducing manufacturing waste as well as rendering waste less toxic. Raymond saner centre for socioeconomic development, gve univ. The triple bottom line 3bl is an expanded version of the business concept of the bottom line that includes social and environmental results as. Second, it will analyze how systems theory and triple bottom line theory support each other. Indiana university kelley school of business, indiana business research center. The triple bottom line 3bl is an expanded version of the business concept of the bottom line that includes social and environmental results as well as financial results. In 2000, under the first sustainability executive briefing.
The triple bottom line considers the different types of impact which can be produced, to varying extents, by business enterprises. More and more businesses are developing strategies for corporate social responsibility csr that aligns with the passions and values of both their leaders and employees. A conceptual framework of sustainability in project management. Maximizing the triple bottom line through spiritual leadership draws on the emerging fields of workplace spirituality and spiritual leadership to teach leaders and their constituencies how to develop business models that address issues of ethical leadership, employee wellbeing, sustainability, and social responsibility without sacrificing profitability, growth, and other. The origin of triple bottom line dates back in 1990s, when the management thought accountability started using the phrase in its work. Business writer john elkington claims to have coined the phrase in 1994. Aug 31, 2009 this effective debunking of the notion of a triple bottom line tbl is 6. Venkatasamy phd envirosolutions ltd mauritius abstract efforts to regulate.
The triple bottom line theory and the organization profits theory are both similar in that each theory advocates a companys right to maximize its profits for the sake of its stockholders. And, finally, does the triple bottom line actually offer a philosophically. Triple bottom line concept one of the foundations of csr is the concept of the triple performance line triple bottom line 3bl, see figure 1, which results from the paradigm of sustainable development and is based on the search for balance between the three dimensions. Integrating ways for employees to give and volunteer their time to causes that align with the companys mission is one way to deliver on the triple bottom line. Triple bottom line tbl is making inroads into public sector performance measurement partly because it is uncertain whether a it is a sound, transparent, and defensible model for transforming and managing public sector agencies.
Using grounded theory as a methodological approach, the influence of triple bottom line tbl was explored as an emerging, yet substantially important phenomenon on strategic positioning through. The triple bottom line refers to economic, environmental, and social value of an. Stenzel the terms sustainability and sustainable development are frequently used in the public arena today. The triple bottom line theory expands the traditional accounting framework to include two other performance areas. Apr 18, 2011 a tbl company endeavors to benefit the natural order as much as possible or at the least do no harm and curtail environmental impact. And, finally, does the triple bottom line actually offer a. Integrating a triple bottomline approach into the management. Getting to the bottom of triple bottom line business. Development of a triple bottom line stakeholder satisfaction model. Apes 14 questions and study guide quizlet flashcards by. Like the csr theory we just discussed, triple bottom line works on the assumption that the corporation is a member of the moral community, and this gives it social responsibilities. A pattern used in technical analysis to predict the reversal of a prolonged downtrend. There is increasing evidence suggesting that environmental and social criteria are impacting the market in complex ways.
Some companies believe corporate social responsibility builds good reputation and customer loyalty. Sustainability is often identified as a primary goal of businesses and organizations, but actually measuring sustainability can be a challenge. Douglas mitchell in 2006 explains that if you were traditionally trainedyou probably heard that the purpose of a corporation is to reward its. The envision framework is an increasingly used and industrywide approach to evaluating tbl benefits. The triple bottom line tbl is a framework or theory that recommends that companies commit to focus on social and environmental concerns just as they do on profits. Third, the analysis will analyze how systems theory and triple bottom line theory negate each other. The triple bottom line of 21st century business elkington, 1997. Sustainability is increasingly perceived as a necessary tool for understanding the social, economic, and environmental consequences associated with projects and project management. If youre ready to apply more responsible practices in your business remember. The corporate world has demonstrated a willingness to respond to public pressure for improved performance on noneconomic issues by embracing triple bottom line tbl principles. As a design tool, you can configure development investments for strong results. Dec 08, 2015 the triple bottom line in local government community economic development december 8, 2015 lexi herndon 0 comments a central tenet of community economic development is the belief that in fostering a healthy economy, we are working towards building healthy, vibrant communities.
1559 1574 1398 537 730 1515 803 1131 1682 1652 1181 578 921 69 775 899 1620 864 45 474 942 583 1080 36 736 565 149 1671 921 1652 768 1058 1540 1288 1243 153 835 175 89 63 1486 64 164 388