One would rather give preference to the rule that an individual has to be given the most preferential. One classic statement of the socalled literal rule is in the sussex peerage. Mark pulliam is a lawyer and writer living in austin, texas. Proponents of literalism very often apply the 3 rules above. Doc the mischief rule and the purposive approach lucy. The main aim of the rule is to determine the mischief and defect that the statute in question has set out to remedy, and what ruling would suppress the mischief, and advance the remedy. Under the mischief rule the courts role is to suppress the mischief the act is aimed at and advance the remedy. It was built in 1937 through the federal works project administration. The scarlet letter free pdf ebooks archive by planet pdf. First published fifty years before political correctness became an accepted rule, mischief in greenland is a treasure trove of tilmans observational wit.
Mischief rule judicial interpretation forms wikipedia golden rule law in law, the golden rule, or british rule, is a form of statutory interpretation that allows a judge to depart from a word s normal meaning in order to avoid an result. This rule requires the court to look to what the law was before the statute was passed in order to discover what gap or mischief the statute was intended to cover. What was the mischief and defect that the law did not provide for. The mischief rule of statutory interpretation is the oldest of the rules. The golden rule and the mischief rule both emerged over time,10 but it should not be forgotten that. A rule is a uniform or established course of things.
The mischief rule in heydons case decided in the year 1589 has now acquired the status of a classic rule and is applied very widely in the countries wherein the british common law has taken its roots. Then in 1877 came the golden rule, later called the absurdity. Literal rule and mischief rule in interpretation by g. These rules will be discussed within the body of this essay. The court elected to use the mischief rule to decide the matter. The mischief rule free download as powerpoint presentation. The mischief rule, used to interpret gaps ultra vires parliament intended to cover and apply a ruling that remedies the problem in ambiguous statutes. The literal rule is a rule against using intelligence in understanding language. And a diaphanous garment only accentuates the attraction of a woman and becomes a potential source of mischief. In this rule four things are to be consider i what was the common law before the making of the act. Like the plain meaning rule, it gives the words of a statute their plain, ordinary meaning. In re sussex peerage, it was held that the mischief rule should only be applied where there is ambiguity in the statute. Mischief rule or hydens rule doctrine of purposive interpretationrule of beneficial interpretation.
Presentation on the mischief rules of interpretation introductory speech. Law hangman on the mischief rule of statutory interpretation. Pdf so what the writer s argument download full pdf book. The rule allows statutes to be refined and developed. The mischief rule is a certain rule that judges can apply in statutory interpretation in order to discover parliaments intention. Legislative intent is determined by examining secondary sources, such as committee reports, treatises, law. The other two are the plain meaning rule also known as the literal rule and the golden rule.
Aids to interpretation of statutes law times journal. Apr 18, 2011 the mischief rule is of narrower application than the golden rule or the plain meaning rule, in that it can only be used to interpret a statute and, strictly speaking, only when the statute was passed to remedy a defect in the common law. For example the london and north eastern railway v berriman 1946 case, where the widow couldnt get compensation because the wording of the statute didnt allow for this circumstance. Although it points to a kind of middle ground between the plain meaning or literal rule and the mischief rule, the golden rule is not, in a strict sense, a compromise between them. Court looks at gap in the law that parliament had passed the act to fill and then interprets the act fill that gap and remedy the mischief. The original formulation of the rule in heydons case 1584 76 er 637 included 4 questions the court should ask. Make reader or acrobat the default program for opening pdf. The mischief rule was developed when acts were a minor source of law. The shorter elapsed time made it rather easier to find a crew but the absence of warm tropical passages meant that similar levels of hardship were simply compressed into a shorter timescale. It allows the law to develop to cover advances in medcial science.
It cannot be remedied else, the mischief if detected. Within the context of law, the mischief rule is a rule of statutory interpretation that attempts to determine the legislators intention. Testing the rule lets give this extrastuff rule a test. The mischief rule gives the most discretion to judges and is suited to specific, often ambiguous cases.
Microsoft edge is the default program for opening pdf files on windows 10. The primary rule used in this case is the mischief rule which is established from another landmark case of heydon2. The mischief rule issimilar to the purposiveapproach. Statutory interpretation essay example graduateway. Pursuant to section 4 of the aa, amcons objects are to do the following 3 things. The bicycle was clearly a form of transport and therefore the user was correctly charged. The mischief rule is more flexible than the golden or literal rule, in that the mischief rule requires judges to look over four tasks to ensure that gaps within the law are covered. An interpretation which makes the enactment a consistent whole, should be the aim of the courts and a construction which avoids inconsistency or repugnancy between the various sections or parts of the statute should be adopted. The other two are the mischief rule and the golden rule. Jan 12, 2018 the golden rule, therefore, allows modification of statutes on public policys grounds. Dec 03, 2010 the literal rule is strongly criticised by many lawyers. Mischief rule of statutory interpretation academike. This is not an example of the work produced by our law essay writing service. The literal rule, the golden rule and therefore the mischief rule.
A study on the rules of statutory interpretation international journal. It only allow judges to rewrite statutes that is supported by the parliament. Legal research and writing statutory interpretation worksheet 5. Working on the biggest story of her life, journalist anne rule didn t know that ted bundy, her friend and coworker at a psychological counseling hotline, was the slayer she was hunting. The golden rule, therefore, allows modification of statutes on public policys grounds. Even the high and mighty assembling at the swiss resort recognize, now, that grotesque inequality is the greatest threat to world peace. The mischief rule statutory interpretation virtue scribd. The mischief rule1 is one of three rules of statutory construction traditionally applied by english courts. Mischief rule hangman find cases decided under the mischief rule of statutory interpretation. In this project, the student will be focusing on the application of the mischief rule, how the mischief rule became the purposive approach of interpretation and how it is applied in indian.
The plain meaning rule, also known as the literal rule, is one of three rules of statutory construction traditionally applied by english courts. Simhanjana interpretation salmond defines interpretation as a process by which the court seeks the meaning of legislature through the medium of authoritative forms in which it expresses. The plain meaning rule dictates that statutes are to be interpreted using the. Presentation on the mischief rules of interpretation. Interpretation of statutes mischief rule construction that suppresses even counter mischief has to be adopted. This rule is illustrated in corkery v carpenter 1951 1 kb 102. The main character is an eve, a member of an elite group of beautiful women, hired by unhappy wives, usually on the losing end of prenups who pay to have their husbands seduced. Demonstrate understanding of the literal, goldenand mischief rule. Two such rules of interpretation are the literal rule and the mischief rule.
Ambiguity is present then the mischief rule may be applied. Literal rule literal rule or plain meaning rule is acclaimed as the safest guide to legislative intent, as the legislature is not to be supposed to use words in a statute, in vain. The second largest gingkgo biloba tree in california is in founders park in mischief bay, according to californias registry of big trees. Pdf the duty of courts is to interpret laws to give effect to the intention of the. Interpretation of statutes words notwithstanding anything contained in any other law do not always completely exclude applicability of other law. For the purpose of construction or interpretation, the court has to take recourse to various internal and external aids. A lot has changed in the thirtyseven years since cop hater, the first in the series, was released, and as the books progress, one can watch the evolution of the technology used by police to fight crime from index cards and penciled notes to the advent of computers and much more sophisticated forensics.
So in the case of quintavalle the house of lords used the purposive approach to decide that the cloning of a saviour sibling should be included in the human fertilisation and embryology act as parliament would have wanted this contentious scientific. Sometimes a court discusses all the three approaches. Mischief rule is a principle used for the interpretation of a statute. There are three rules of interpretation of statutes literal, golden and mischief. The golden rule wont help if there is no absurdity in the statute. Anyone who in ordinary life interpreted words literally, being indifferent to what the speaker or writer meant would be regarded as a pedant, a mischief maker or an idiot. Anyone who in ordinary life interpreted words literally, being indifferent to what the speaker or writer meant, would be regarded as a pedant, a mischiefmaker or an idiot. The interpretation of laws is confined to courts of law. Demonstrate understanding of the cases in relationto the rules. The mischief rule 1 is one of three rules of statutory construction traditionally applied by english courts. It is an accepted fact that words have no proper or specific meaning until they are put into a context of situation. The mischief rule was established in heydons case 1584 ewhc exch j36 case summary.
Any form of mischief is eliminated to lead to more effective judgments. The mischief bay post office is a worldrenowned example of art deco architecture. This principle was first applied in an english case in the early 16th century. Although legislature makes the statute, it may be open to interpretation and have ambiguities. This is effectively a purposive approach qualified contextualism, but it is confined to instances of ambiguity. There is a tremendous output of federal, state and territory legislation. Anyone who in ordinary life interpreted words literally, being indifferent to what the speaker or writer meant would be regarded as a pedant, a mischiefmaker or an idiot. The court had to decide if the word prostitution was a word that could only. The prostitutes were soliciting from private premises in windows or on balconies so could be seen by the public. The case of adler v george 1964 is a classic example of the courts applying the golden rule. The interpretation is favoured that remedies the problem or mischief thus, no. Know the assignment, be the assignment one of the top mistakes new writers make is not following directions, not fully. You can change the default program for pdf files to open it in a program thats more suitable and featurerich, such as acrobat reader dc or acrobat dc. The purposes for reading assessment include comparing one childs progress to that of his peers, screening students for special assistance, measuring an individuals progress over a period of time, diagnosing particular areas of strength or weakness, using information for.
Discuss the rules of statutary interpretation with the. The assessment of childrens reading progress has long been of interest to teachers, researchers, and parents. When pound was writing, courts were positioned well and truly in the fourth category. The rule of harmonious construction is the thumb rule to interpretation of any statute. The main aim of the rule is to determine the mischief and defect that the statute in question has set out to remedy, and what ruling would effectively implement this. The mischief rule tells an interpreter to read a statute in light of the. As byatt is a clever writer who has often been accused of being too clever. The prostitutes were soliciting from private premises in windows oron balconies so could be seen by the public. The golden rule tries to compliment the literal rule by allowing judges to change the meaning of statutes in order to give justice.
Heydons case 1584 3 rep 7a was the statute aiming to resolve and how best to address that mischief. This is a simple declaratory sentence with an easily identified subject judge, verb granted, and object motion. The mischief rule purpose approach is applied by judges in the determination of any mischief in the statute. This book, which was first published in 1993, is the 45th entry in the 87th precinct series.
However, when this may lead to an irrational result that acropdf a quality pdf writer and pdf converter to create pdf. Mischief rule advantages and disadvantages flashcards. Apply the mischief rule to various sources andengage in discussion. The defendants were prostitutes who had been charged under thestreet offences act 1959 which made it an offence to solicit in a publicplace.
She was born may 2 in pittsburgh, pennsylvania to d. For the purpose of construction or interpretation, the court has to take recourse to. This principle aims at finding out the mischief and defect in a statute and to implement a remedy for the same. As explained below, the mischief rule enables the court to adopt a statutory construction that conflicts with the statutes apparent plain meaningwhile still claiming. Martha grimes is an american author of detective fiction. Pdf presentation on the mischief rules of interpretation.
Martha grimes author of the man with a load of mischief. The supposition is that by strictly limiting what can be done, to whom and by whom, the evilness of the action is negated. It would be better for the law to remain fixed rather than have judges making changes to acts. Mischief goes south is an account of a voyage marred by tragedy and dogged by crew trouble from the start. Mischief rule of statutory interpretation academike lawctopus. The mischief rule legal definition of the mischief rule. In 1844 came the i jteral rule, which said, they alone do, in such a case, best declare the intention of the lawgiver. The literal rule is strongly criticised by many lawyers. If the plain meaning of the word is ambiguous, vague or misleading or if a strict literal interpretation would result in absurd results.
The purpose of the act was to prevent people from using any form of transport on a public highway whilst in a state of intoxication. The mischief rule is of narrower application than the golden rule or the plain meaning rule, in that it can only be used to interpret a statute and, strictly speaking, only when the statute was passed to remedy a defect in the common law. An aid, on the other hand is a device that helps or assists. The mischief rule is one of three rules of statutory interpretation traditionally applied by english courts. A statute, which is a bill or law passed by the legislature, imposes obligations and rules on the people.
Supreme court of appeal ruled that the common denominator rule is not a rule of general application. The golden rule under the golden rule for statutory interpretation, where the literal rule gives an absurd result, which parliament could not have intended, the judge can substitute a reasonable meaning in the light of the statute as a whole. Like the plain meaning rule, the golden rule gives the words of a statute their plain, ordinary meaning. The writers argument, second edition, teaches students how to write compelling arguments and explains why practicing argumentation is essential to learning and communicating with others. Advantages and disadvantages of using the mischief rule.
An article should provide a comprehensive analysis of a particular issue on a particular subject area. Mischief rule lesson powerpoint linkedin slideshare. Jun 05, 2018 the mischief rule purpose approach is applied by judges in the determination of any mischief in the statute. Originating from a 16th century case in the united kingdom, its main aim is to determine the mischief and defect that the statute in question has set out to remedy. Golden rule of interpretation essay sample new york essays. The third rule of the hijab, according to the writer, is that the garment should not be thin because a thin cloth can never provide cover. This third rule gives a judge more discretion than either the literal or the golden rule. Criticism 1 the mischief rule acknowledges the application. There are two equally important elements to this view. Methods of statutory interpretation qualityessay net. Today bundy is in prison, convicted of mass sexual abuse and murder. There has been a noticeable shift in the expression of law from court judgments to expositions in legislation. Statutory interpretation refers to the process by which a court looks at a statute and determines what it means. Tilman gives ample insight into the difficulties associated with his selection of shipmates and his supervision of a crew, as he wryly notes, to have four misfits in a crew of five is too many.
This principle is used by the courts to determine the intention of the legislators. Whether for her own good or for ours is a moot point. The purpose of interpretation is always to find out what the statute stands for, what is the defect it. Heydons case 1584 76 er 637 is considered a landmark case as it was the first case to use what would come to be called the mischief rule for statutory interpretation. Download pdf mischiefgoessouth free online new books in. Smith v hughes 1960 1 wlr 830 the defendants were prostitutes who had been charged under the street offences act 1959 which made it an offence to solicit in a public place. Golden rule it is a compromise between the plain meaning or literal rule and the mischief rule. Mar 11, 20 nicole williams great exploitations is a clever series of novellas, the first of which is mischief in miami. Pdf taming the unruly horse of rules of interpretation. A graduate of the university of texas school of law, mark practiced law in california for 30 years with a large law firm, where he was recognized as one of the best lawyers in america. In this case the house of lords had to decide if it was legal for nurses to administer hormones to induce abortions. Although the literal rule is the one most frequently referred to in express terms, the courts treat all three viz. Mischief rule law and legal definition uslegal, inc. Explain the difference between the literal, golden and mischief rule.
1592 48 168 157 1211 1665 905 1572 387 502 1591 458 59 1266 953 1631 1577 381 1028 960 1433 1566 839 1430 1425 425 370 243 1132 772 652 880 1167 1232 59 944 517 106